Wednesday, September 25, 2019

Nonattest Services

Part 1:

Service Type of Service
1. Valuation services Nonattest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct includes specific examples of nonattest services performed by members that should be taken into account when determining independence with respect to a client. Those services include valuation services. [ET 1.295.110]

2. Agreed-upon services Attest service
An agreed-upon procedures engagement is one in which a practitioner is engaged to issue, or does issue, a practitioner's report of findings based on specific agreed-upon procedures applied to subject matter for use by specified parties. This is considered an attest service. [AT-C 215.02]

3. Financial statement preparation Nonattest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct includes specific examples of nonattest services performed by members that should be taken into account when determining independence with respect to a client. Those services include financial statement and footnote preparation. [ET 1.295.120]

4. Compilation Attest service
A compilation is a service that assists management in presenting financial information in the form of financial statements without undertaking to obtain or provide any assurance that there are no material modifications that should be made to the financial statements in order for the statements to be in conformity with the applicable financial reporting framework. A compilation is an attest engagement, but not an assurance engagement. [SSARS No. 21, 70.04]

5. Executive or employee recruiting Nonattest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct includes specific examples of nonattest services performed by members that should be taken into account when determining independence with respect to a client. Those services include executive or employee recruiting. [ET 1.295.135]

6. Tax return preparation services Nonattest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct includes specific examples of nonattest services performed by members that should be taken into account when determining independence with respect to a client. Those services include tax return services. [ET 1.295.160]

7. Cash to accrual adjustments Nonattest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct includes specific examples of nonattest services performed by members that should be taken into account when determining independence with respect to a client. Those services include cash to accrual adjustments. [ET 1.295.06]

8. Communication between auditor and client regarding the form and content of financial statements Attest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct states that communications between a member and client regarding the form and content of financial statements are considered part of the attest engagement. [ET 1.295.010.04]

9. Providing advice to the client on routine business matters Nonattest service
Providing advice to the client on routine business matters is considered a routine activity, which is defined to include providing advice or assistance to the client on an informal basis as part of the client-member relationship. These services are generally insignificant in terms of time incurred or resources expended, typically do not produce a formal report or deliverable, and are considered to be a nonattest service. [ET 1.295.105]

10. Bookkeeping and payroll Nonattest service
The independence section of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct includes specific examples of nonattest services performed by members that should be taken into account when determining independence with respect to a client. Those services include bookkeeping and payroll services. [ET 1.295.120]

Part 2:


Safeguard Answer
1. The auditor determines that the attest client and its management agree to: evaluate the adequacy and results of the services performed.
An acceptable safeguard to the auditor’s independence exists when management agrees to evaluate the adequacy and results of the services performed. [ET 1.295.040]

2. The auditor does not assume management responsibilities when providing nonattest services and is satisfied that the attest client and its management will: make an informed judgment on the results of the member’s nonattest services.
An acceptable safeguard to the auditor’s independence exists when the auditor is satisfied that the attest client and its management will make an informed judgment on the results of the auditor’s nonattest services. [ET 1.295.040]

3. Before performing nonattest services, the auditor establishes and documents in writing his or her understanding with the attest client regarding: any limitations of the engagement.
An acceptable safeguard to the auditor’s independence exists when the auditor establishes and documents in writing his or her understanding with the attest client regarding any limitations of the engagement. [ET 1.295.040]

4. The person designated by management to oversee the nonattest service: should understand the nature of the service being rendered.
The person designated by management to oversee the nonattest service should understand the nature of the service being rendered and possess a sufficient knowledge of the attest client’s business and industry. The individual is not required to supervise the member in the day-to-day rendering of the services, nor is it required that the individual possess the expertise to perform or re-perform the services. [Frequently Asked Questions: Nonattest Services Questions, AICPA Professional Ethics Division]



Part 3:


Reconciling Item Resolution
[1] Balance per bank, 1/2/Y4, $60,000 Requires follow-up
The reconciliation (Document #1) should have been agreed to the ending bank balance as of 12/31/Y3, not the balance as of 1/2/Y4. Bank activity that occurred on January 1 and January 2 of Y4 would not be included in the reconciliation, and errors or fraud could go undetected. The auditor should follow up with management on this issue.

[2] Deposit in transit, 11/28/Y3, $15,000 Requires follow-up
A deposit in transit is a proper reconciling item; however, the deposit dated 11/28/Y3 for $15,000 should not still be an outstanding item on the December reconciliation. Given that there has been significant turnover in the Cash Management department, the auditor should follow up with management on this issue.

[3] Outstanding check #7544, 8/29/Y3, $10,000 Requires follow-up
The outstanding checks from August should have been investigated and resolved, not still listed on the reconciliation without any documentation by the client. Old checks should be resolved by attempting to contact the payee and then taking the appropriate action. The auditor should follow up with management on this issue.

[4] Outstanding check #8157, $5,000 Requires follow-up
Outstanding check #8157, $5,000 is an addition to the bank balance instead of a deduction, resulting in an incorrect adjusted bank balance. The auditor should follow up with management on this issue.

[5] Less: bank service fees, $200 Requires follow-up
Bank service fees of $200 have already been deducted from the bank balance, and should be a reduction of the book balance. Including it as a reconciling item to the bank balance has resulted in an incorrect ending cash balance, and requires follow up with management.

[6] Balance per books before adjs., 12/31/Y4, $55,000 Properly documented
The unadjusted balance per books for 12/31/Y4 of $55,000 agrees with the General Ledger Balance document (Document #2) and is properly documented. (Note that the report was appropriately run on January 4, Year 4, before the adjusting journal entry was recorded.)

[7] Net adjustment, $9,800 Requires follow-up
The client recorded the net difference between the reconciled bank balance (which was identified to be incorrect in the previous items) with a net plug to Other Income (see General Journal, Document #3). Each reconciling item made to the book balance only (not the bank balance) should be separately adjusted in the journal entry. The auditor should follow up with management on this issue.

[8] Reviewed by: Tyler Brooke, 1/6/Y4 Requires follow-up
Bank reconciliations should be reviewed by a different person than the preparer of the reconciliation; however, the reviewer should possess sufficient knowledge and understanding of the process. Tyler Brooke is a sales manager, which would raise concerns that he may not possess the skills necessary to detect errors or fraud. Kloe Steele, controller, would be a more appropriate reviewer. The auditor should follow up with management on this issue.

No comments:

Post a Comment