Saturday, September 21, 2019

Attorney Letters (Simulation)

Situations Audit Response
(Financials) Audit Response
(Report)

1) Letter dated February 14, Year 2:

"I advise you that at and since December 31, Year 1, I have not been engaged to give substantive attention to, or represent XYZ Co. in connection with any pending or threatened litigation, claims, or assessments, nor am I aware of any loss contingencies. No amounts were due to this office for services provided at December 31, Year 1." No impact on financial statement or footnotes Legal response is appropriately dated
The attorney was not engaged to give substantive attention regarding threatened litigation, claims, or assessments. Therefore, there would be no financial impact. AU-C 501.A69 shows an example of an audit inquiry letter stating that the attorney's response should be received within two weeks of the report date. Since the response was received only one day prior to the report date, no update is necessary.
2) Letter dated January 21, Year 2:

"I advise you that at and since December 31, Year 1, I have not been engaged to give substantive attention to, or represent XYZ Co. in connection with any pending or threatened litigation, claims, or assessments, nor am I aware of any loss contingencies. There were fees outstanding of $3,675 due to this office for services provided at December 31, Year 1." Verify amount due attorney is recorded in financial statements Update legal response
The attorney was not engaged to give any substantive attention to threatened litigation, claims, or assessments; therefore, there is no need to accrue any contingent liability. However, the auditor should verify that the amount due to the attorney had been accrued by the client. The attorney's response was received more than two weeks prior to the report date. Therefore, the auditor should get an updated response from the attorney.
3) Letter dated February 26, Year 2:

"I advise you that at and since December 31, Year 1, I have not been engaged to give substantive attention to, or represent XYZ Co. in connection with any pending or threatened litigation, claims, or assessments, except as follows:

"K. Bowt v. XYZ Co.: This matter commenced in December, Year 1. The plaintiff alleges discrimination relating to his termination on November 17, Year 1. The company intends to defend this case vigorously. At this time, we are unable to evaluate the likelihood of an unfavorable outcome or estimate the amount or range of potential loss." Disclosure in footnotes relating to nature of litigation, but no amount disclosed Update report date
FASB ASC 450-20-50 states that the disclosure of a noted contingency should include the nature of the contingency and an estimate of the possible loss or range of loss. FASB ASC 450-20-50-5 states that disclosure is preferable to accrual when a reasonable estimate of loss cannot be made. Since a disclosure is now required to be made in the financial statements and the knowledge of this event occurred after the original report date, the report date should be updated.
4) Letter dated March 16, Year 2:

"I advise you that at and since December 31, Year 1, I have not been engaged to give substantive attention to, or represent XYZ Co. in connection with any pending or threatened litigation, claims, or assessments, except as follows:

"J. Myers v. XYZ Co.: This matter commenced in March, Year 2. The plaintiff alleges discrimination relating to his termination on November 17, Year 1. The company intends to defend this case vigorously. At this time, we are unable to evaluate the likelihood of an unfavorable outcome. The plaintiff is demanding $50,000." Disclosure in footnotes relating to nature of litigation, but no amount disclosed Update report date
Since the attorney was not able to evaluate the likelihood of an unfavorable outcome, a loss contingency amount cannot be disclosed, but as noted above, the nature of the contingency should be disclosed under FASB ASC 450-20-50. Since a disclosure is now required to be made in the financial statements and the knowledge of this event occurred after the original report date, the report date should be updated.
5) Letter dated January 10, Year 2:

"I advise you that at and since December 31, Year 1, I have not been engaged to give substantive attention to, or represent XYZ Co. in connection with any pending or threatened litigation, claims, or assessments, except as follows:

"R. Brown v. XYZ Co.: This matter commenced in November, Year 1. The plaintiff alleges discrimination relating to his termination on March 17, Year 1. The case was tentatively settled for $35,000, which will be covered by XYZ's insurance carrier." Potential litigation settlement not accrued in financial statements, amount disclosed in footnotes Update legal response
In accordance with FASB ASC 450-20-50, the potential litigation settlement will need to be disclosed in the financial statement. However, there is no need to accrue the settlement since this will be paid for by the insurance carrier. The legal response was received prior to the report date, so therefore there is no need to update the report. However, the letter was received more than two weeks prior to the report date, so the legal response must be updated.

6) Letter dated January 20, Year 2:

"I advise you that at and since December 31, Year 1, I have not been engaged to give substantive attention to, or represent XYZ Co. in connection with any pending or threatened litigation, claims, or assessments, except as follows:

"L. Peep v. XYZ Co.: This matter commenced in November, Year 1. The plaintiff alleges discrimination relating to his termination on March 17, Year 1. The case was tentatively settled for $35,000." Potential litigation settlement accrued in financial statements Update legal response
In accordance with FASB ASC 450-20-50, the potential litigation settlement must be accrued since estimated loss could be made. Since the legal letter was received more than two weeks prior to the report date, the legal response should be updated.

No comments:

Post a Comment