Sunday, September 22, 2019

Misstatements Simulation

Misstatement
Audit Procedure Used to Detect Misstatement
Internal Control That Could Prevent or Detect Misstatement in the Future

1. An accounts payable clerk misplaces year-end invoices for raw materials that were received on December 21, Year 2, and therefore liabilities were not recorded. 

Investigate unmatched receiving reports dated prior to January 1, Year 3.

 The purchasing department supervisor forwards a monthly listing of matched purchase orders and receiving reports to the accounts payable supervisor for comparison to a listing of vouched invoices.

The liability for payment at the end of Year 2 exists because items were received prior to year-end. Each receiving report should have at least one corresponding vendor invoice matched with it. The auditor found unmatched receiving reports for the period under audit and then determined that the vendor invoices were misplaced.

Only one other answer choice deals with receiving reports; however, it involves tracing those reports to packing slips (not vendor invoices).

Requesting confirmation from the accounts payable supervisor that all invoices are recorded does not provide evidence regarding missing invoices.
The concern is that vendor invoices may have been misplaced before they are recorded. To prevent this occurrence, or to prompt the accounts payable clerk to look for what appears to be a missing invoice, information on products ordered and received must come from another department. A comparison of this listing to the vouched invoices will highlight any missing invoices.

While copying all vendor invoices and storing them offsite may provide a more complete body of vendor invoices should one go missing, the control must involve the other forms of documentation that make the vendor invoice a liability. These forms would be the purchase order and the receiving report.

2. The company tends to be careless in recording payables in the correct period. 

From the January, Year 3, cash disbursements journal, select payments and match to corresponding invoices. 

A clerk is responsible for matching purchase orders with receiving reports and making certain they are included in the proper month.

This misstatement deals with cutoff. The auditor was concerned that payables may have been recorded in Year 3 when they should have been recorded in Year 2. Any outstanding receivable at the end of Year 2 would have been paid in January, Year 3. Examining the payments in the January, Year 3, cash disbursements journal and viewing the corresponding vendor invoice allowed the auditor to discover that some payables were not recorded in the correct period.

Reviewing the cash disbursement journal for December, Year 2, would provide the auditor with payments for accounts payable already recorded prior to year-end. The auditor must look outside of Year 2 to help with the cutoff determination.

Identifying open purchase orders and vendors’ invoices at December 31, Year 2, would not help the auditor to determine if any invoices were recorded in Year 3 that should have been recorded in Year 2.
The control needed is a matter of matching and checking. If a clerk is assigned the specific duty to match purchase orders with receiving reports and then make sure they are recorded in the proper month, payables should be recorded in the correct period in the future.

3. The company has the same person approving pay requests and cutting checks. 

Select an unpaid invoice and ask to be walked through the invoice payment process. 

Accounts payable personnel are assigned different responsibilities each quarter within the department.

The auditor would usually determine the separation of duties (or lack thereof) by inquiry and observation. Asking the accounts payable department to demonstrate, or walk the auditor through, the accounts payable process would allow the auditor to see who is responsible for which procedure.
Separating or rotating job duties will prevent the same person from having control over both authorization and recording functions.

4. The company's receiving department misplaces receiving reports for purchases of raw materials at year-end and therefore liabilities were not recorded. 

Identify open purchase orders and vendors' invoices at December 31, Year 2, and investigate their disposition. 

The accounts payable supervisor reviews a monthly listing of open purchase orders and vendors' invoices for follow-up with the receiving department.

Receiving reports, vendor invoices, and purchase orders are matched together in the accounts payable department before payment can be authorized and recorded. The vendor invoice is not a payable until the order has been received. If the auditor questioned any unmatched invoices or purchase orders ("Did you receive this item? If so, when?"), any misplaced receiving reports and unrecorded liabilities would be revealed.

Reviewing the receiving department’s filing system and investigating unmatched receiving reports dated prior to January 1, Year 3, would not reveal missing receiving reports. The auditor must look at other documentation that would highlight the missing reports.
Since the accounts payable department may be missing information, it should prepare a listing of open items that are waiting for receiving reports to ask the receiving department if the shipments have been received ("And if so, when? And where is the receiving report?"). The request has to originate from the accounts payable department, not the receiving or purchasing departments.

No comments:

Post a Comment