Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Contingent liabilites

A CPA had the management of Paper Plate Corp. prepare a letter requesting Paper Plate's external counsel to identify any pending and/or unasserted claims against Paper Plate. The CPA received a letter from the external counsel with the following response:

"We are only aware of the following: Paper Plate was named as the defendant in a class action lawsuit for an alleged defective product manufactured two years ago. There is a remote possibility that Paper Plate will suffer any damages, because this firm has successfully defended similar cases in the past. However, similar cases that have been brought against competitors were settled between $1.5 and $2 million."

Should the CPA accept the letter from the external counsel?

  • No, because the CPA allowed Paper Plate to prepare the letter
  • Yes, even though the CPA did not get a specific amount of loss (correct answer)
  • No, because the CPA did not consult a specialist in class action suits
  • Yes, if the CPA discusses the prior lawsuits with the competitors' lawyers
Explanation:

The legal representation letter should obtain evidence about any litigation, claims, assessments, and unasserted claims that either management or counsel is aware of, together with an assessment of the outcome of the litigation, claims, and assessments, and an estimate of the financial implications, including costs involved. The lawyer is asked to indicate a description of the nature of the matter, the progress of the case to date, and action the company intends to take; an evaluation of an unfavorable outcome; and an estimated range (if estimable) of potential loss. It is not mandatory that the attorney provide a specific amount for any estimated loss. A lawyer may limit a response to matters to which the lawyer has given substantive attention and to matters which individually or collectively are material to the financial statements.

No comments:

Post a Comment