Sunday, July 28, 2019

Which of the following presumptions is correct about the reliability of audit evidence?

Which of the following presumptions is correct about the reliability of audit evidence?
  • Information obtained indirectly from outside sources is the most reliable audit evidence. (should obtained directly)
  • To be reliable, audit evidence should be convincing rather than persuasive.
  • Reliability of audit evidence refers to the amount of corroborative evidence obtained.
  • Effective internal control provides more assurance about the reliability of audit evidence. (correct answer)
Explanation:

Effective internal control provides more assurance about the reliability of audit evidence, specifically, more about the reliability of the accounting data and financial statements. In addition, more assurance about the reliability of audit evidence is also provided when information is obtained directly, not indirectly, by the auditor or from outside, independent sources.

Audit evidence is usually persuasive (that is, influencing or causing a person to believe by appealing to understanding), rather than convincing (a concept of criminal law: “beyond a reasonable doubt”). Thus professional judgment is required in the evaluation of the reliability and sufficiency of audit evidence.

It is the quality, not the quantity, of corroborative evidence that is important to the reliability of evidence. Frequently, corroborative evidence is internal (e.g., checks and invoices). Thus, a small amount of highly reliable (i.e., external) evidence is more reliable than a large about of internal corroborating evidence.

No comments:

Post a Comment